Skip Navigation LinksHome > Case Documents > Granted/Noted Cases List > October Term 2016

16 GN List

 

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

CASES FOR ARGUMENT IN OCTOBER TERM 2016

 

As of June 23, 2017

 

14-1055*         CFX     LIGHTFOOT V. CENDANT MORTGAGE CORP.

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  6/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  11/8/16                                Decided:  1/18/17

                                    Author:  J. Sotomayor

                                    Result:  REVERSED

 

14-1538#         CFX     LIFE TECHNOLOGIES CORP. V. PROMEGA CORP.

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed.                                         Granted:  6/27/16

                                    Argument Date:  12/6/16                                Decided:  2/22/17

                                    Author:  J. Sotomayor                                                Other:  Alito (C/P, C/J)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED   CJ out

 

14-9496           CFX     MANUEL V. CITY OF JOLIET

                                    Court:  USCA-7                                              Granted:  1/15/16

                                    Argument Date:  10/5/16                                Decided:  3/21/17

                                    Author:   J. Kagan                                           Other:  Thomas (D); Alito (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

15-118             CFX     HERNANDEZ V. MESA

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                              Granted:  10/11/16

                                    Argument Date:  2/21/17

 

15-214             CSX    MURR V. WISCONSIN

                                    Court:  Ct. App. Wis., Dist. III                          Granted:  1/15/16

                                    Argument Date:  3/20/17                                Decided:  6/23/17

                                    Author:  J. Kennedy                                        Other:  Chief Justice (D); Thomas (D)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED (NMG   no part)

 

15-423*           CFX     BOLIVARIAN REP. OF VENEZUELA V. HELMERICH & PAYNE

                                    Court:  USCA-DC                                           Granted:  6/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  11/2/16                                Decided:  5/1/17

                                    Author:  J. Breyer                                          

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED (NMG   no part)

                                   

 

15-457#           CFX     MICROSOFT CORP. V. BAKER

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  1/15/16

                                    Argument Date:  3/21/17                                Decided:  6/12/17

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg                                        Other:  Thomas (C/J)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (NMG   no part)

 

15-497#           CFX     FRY V. NAPOLEON COMMUNITY SCHOOLS

                                    Court:  USCA-6                                              Granted:  6/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  10/31/16                              Decided:  2/22/17

                                    Author:  J. Kagan                                            Other:  Alito (C/P, C/J)

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

 

15-513*           CFX     STATE FARM FIRE & CASUALTY CO. V. UNITED STATES, EX REL. RIGSBY

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                              Granted:  5/31/16

                                    Argument Date:  11/1/16                                Decided:  12/6/16

                                    Author:  J. Kennedy

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

15-537*           CFY     BRAVO-FERNANDEZ V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-1                                              Granted:  3/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  10/4/16                                Decided:  11/29/16

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg                                        Other:  Thomas (C)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

15-577             CFX     TRINITY LUTHERAN CHURCH V. COMER

                                    Court:  USCA-8                                              Granted:  1/15/16

                                    Argument Date:  4/19/17

 

15-606             CSY    PENA-RODRIGUEZ V. COLORADO

                                    Court:  SC-CO                                                            Granted:  4/4/16

                                    Argument Date:  10/11/16                              Decided:  3/6/17

                                    Author:  J. Kennedy                                        Other:  Thomas (D); Alito (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

15-628*           CFY     SALMAN V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  1/19/16

                                    Argument Date:  10/5/16                                Decided:  12/6/16

                                    Author:  J. Alito

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

15-649             CFX     CZYZEWSKI V. JEVIC HOLDING CORP.

                                    Court:  USCA-3                                              Granted:  6/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  12/7/16                                Decided:  3/22/17

                                    Author:  J. Breyer                                           Other:  Thomas (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

15-680             ATX     BETHUNE-HILL V. VA STATE BOARD OF ELECTIONS

                                    Court:  USDC-E. Dist. Va.                              Noted:  6/6/16

                                    Argument Date:  12/5/16                                Decided:  3/1/17

                                    Author:  J. Kennedy                                        Other:  Alito (C/P, C/J)

                                                                                                                        Thomas (C/J/P, D/P)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED IN PART, VACATED IN PART, AND REMANDED

 

15-777*           CFX     SAMSUNG ELECTRONICS CO. V. APPLE INC.

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed.                                         Granted:  3/21/16

                                    Argument Date:  10/11/16                              Decided:  12/6/16

                                    Author:  J. Sotomayor

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

15-797             CSH    MOORE V. TEXAS

                                    Court:  Crim. App. Tex.                                  Granted:  6/6/16

                                    Argument Date:  11/29/16                              Decided:  3/28/17

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg                                        Other:  Chief Justice (D)

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

15-827*           CFX     ENDREW F. V. DOUGLAS COUNTY SCHOOL DIST. RE-1

                                    Court:  USCA-10                                            Granted:  9/29/16

                                    Argument Date:  1/11/17                                Decided:  3/22/17

                                    Author:  Chief Justice

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

15-866             CFX     STAR ATHLETICA, L.L.C. V. VARSITY BRANDS, INC.

                                    Court:  USCA-6                                              Granted:  5/2/16

                                    Argument Date:  10/31/16                              Decided:  3/22/17

                                    Author:  J. Thomas                                         Other:  Ginsburg (C/J); Breyer (D)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

15-927             CFX     SCA HYGIENE PRODUCTS V. FIRST QUALITY BABY PRODUCTS

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed.                                         Granted:  5/2/16

                                    Argument Date:  11/1/16                                Decided:  3/21/17

                                    Author:  J. Alito                                               Other:  Breyer (D)

                                    Result:  VACATED IN PART AND REMANDED

 

15-1031#         CSX    HOWELL V. HOWELL

                                    Court:  SC-AZ                                                 Granted:  12/2/16

                                    Argument Date:  3/20/17                                Decided:  5/15/17

                                    Author:  J. Breyer                                           Other:  Thomas (C/P, C/J)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (NMG   no part) 

 

15-1039)*        CFX     SANDOZ INC. V. AMGEN INC.

15-1195)*        CFX     AMGEN INC. V. SANDOZ INC.

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed.                                         Granted:  1/13/17

                                    Argument Date:  4/26/17                                Decided:  6/12/17

                                    Author:  J. Thomas                                         Other:  Breyer (C)

                                    Result:  VACATED IN PART, REVERSED IN PART, AND REMANDED

 

15-1111)          CFX     BANK OF AMERICA CORP. V. MIAMI

15-1112)          CFX     WELLS FARGO & CO. V. MIAMI

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                            Granted:  6/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  11/8/16                                Decided:  5/1/17

                                    Author:            J. Breyer                                            Other: Thomas (C/P, D/P)

                                    Result:   VACATED AND REMANDED  (NMG   no part) 

 

15-1189           CFX     IMPRESSION PRODUCTS V. LEXMARK INTERNATIONAL

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed.                                         Granted:  12/2/16

                                    Argument Date:  3/21/17                                Decided:  5/30/17

                                    Author:  Chief Justice                                     Other:  Ginsburg (C/P, D/P)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (NMG   no part)

 

15-1191           CFX     SESSIONS, ATT Y GEN. V. MORALES-SANTANA

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  6/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  11/9/16                                Decided:  6/12/17

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg                                        Other:  Thomas (C/J/P)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED IN PART, REVERSED IN PART, AND REMANDED

                                                  (NMG   no part)

 

15-1194#         CSY    PACKINGHAM v. NORTH CAROLINA

                                    Court:  SC-NC                                                            Granted:  10/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  2/27/17                                Decided:  6/19/17

                                    Author:  J. Kennedy                                        Other:  Alito (C/J)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (NMG   no part)

 

15-1204           CFH    JENNINGS V. RODRIGUEZ

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  6/20/16

                                    Argument Date:  11/30/16

 

15-1248           CFX     McLANE V. EEOC

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  9/29/16

                                    Argument Date:  2/21/17                                Decided:  4/3/17

                                    Author:  J. Sotomayor                                                Other:  Ginsburg (C/P, D/P)

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

15-1251           CFX     NLRB V. SW GENERAL, INC.

                                    Court:  USCA-DC                                           Granted:  6/20/16

                                    Argument Date:  11/7/16                                Decided:  3/21/17

                                    Author:  Chief Justice                                     Other:  Thomas (C); Sotomayor (D)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

15-1256           CSY    NELSON V. COLORADO

                                    Court:  SC-CO                                                            Granted:  9/29/16

                                    Argument Date:  1/9/17                                  Decided:  4/19/17

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg                                        Other:  Alito (C/J); Thomas (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (NMG   no part)

 

15-1262           ATX     COOPER, GOV. OF NC V. HARRIS

                                    Court:  USDC-Mid. Dist. NC                          Noted:  6/27/16

                                    Argument Date:  12/5/16                                Decided:  5/22/17

                                    Author:  J. Kagan                                            Other:  Thomas (C); Alito (C/J/P, D/P)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED (NMG   no part)

 

15-1293#         CFX     MATAL, INTERIM DIR., U.S. PATENT & TRADEMARK OFFICE V. TAM

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed.                                         Granted:  9/29/16

                                    Argument Date:  1/18/17                                Decided:  6/19/17

                                    Author:  J. Alito                                               Other:  Kennedy (C/P, C/J)

                                                                                                                        Thomas (C/P, C/J)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED (NMG   no part)

15-1358)          CFX     ZIGLAR V. ABBASI

15-1359)          CFX     ASHCROFT V. ABBASI

15-1363)          CFX     HASTY V. ABBASI

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  10/11/16 (SS & EK   no part)

                                    Argument Date:  1/18/17                                Decided:  6/19/17

                                    Author:  J. Kennedy                                        Other:  Thomas (C/P, C/J); Breyer (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED IN PART, VACATED AND REMANDED IN PART

                                                   (SS, EK & NMG   no part)

 

15-1391#         CFX     EXPRESSIONS HAIR DESIGN V. SCHNEIDERMAN, ATT Y GEN. OF NY

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  9/29/16

                                    Argument Date:  1/10/17                                Decided:  3/29/17

                                    Author:  Chief Justice                                     Other:  Breyer (C/J); Sotomayor (C/J)

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

15-1406*         CFX     GOODYEAR TIRE & RUBBER CO. V. HAEGER

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  9/29/16

                                    Argument Date:  1/10/17                                Decided:  4/18/17

                                    Author:  J. Kagan                                           

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (NMG   no part) 

 

15-1498           CFX     SESSIONS, ATT Y GEN. V. DIMAYA

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  9/29/16

                                    Argument Date:  1/17/17

 

15-1500#         CSX    LEWIS V. CLARKE  

                                    Court:  SC-CT                                                 Granted:  9/29/16

                                    Argument Date:  1/9/17                                  Decided:  4/25/17

                                    Author:  J. Sotomayor                                                Other:  Thomas (C/J); Ginsburg (C/J)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (NMG   no part)

 

15-1503)          CSH    TURNER V. UNITED STATES

15-1504)          CSH    OVERTON V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court: CA-DC                                                 Granted: 12/14/16

                                    Argument Date:  3/29/17                                Decided:  6/22/17

                                    Author:  J. Breyer                                           Other:  Kagan (D)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED (NMG   no part)           

 

15-5991*         CFY     SHAW V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  4/25/16

                                    Argument Date:  10/4/16                                Decided: 12/12/16

                                    Author: J. Breyer

                                    Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

 

15-7250           CFY     MANRIQUE V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                            Granted:  4/25/16

                                    Argument Date:  10/11/16                              Decided:  4/19/17

                                    Author:  J. Thomas                                         Other:  Ginsburg (D)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED (NMG   no part)

 

15-8049           CFH    BUCK V. DAVIS

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                              Granted:  6/6/16

                                    Argument Date:  10/5/16                                Decided:  2/22/17

                                    Author:  Chief Justice                                     Other:  Thomas (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

15-8544#         CFH    BECKLES V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                            Granted:  6/27/16 (EK   no part)

                                    Argument Date:  11/28/16                              Decided:  3/6/17

                                    Author:  J. Thomas                                         Other:  Kennedy (C)

                                                                                                                        Ginsburg (C/J); Sotomayor (C/J)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED (EK   no part)

 

15-9260*         CFY     DEAN V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-8                                              Granted:  10/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  2/28/17                                Decided:  4/3/17

                                    Author:  Chief Justice                                    

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

16-32               CSX    KINDRED NURSING CENTERS V. CLARK

                                    Court:  SC-KY                                                 Granted:  10/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  2/22/17                                Decided:  5/15/17

                                    Author:  J. Kagan                                            Other:  Thomas (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED IN PART, VACATED IN PART, AND REMANDED

                                                 (NMG   no part)

 

16-54*             CFX     ESQUIVEL-QUINTANA V. SESSIONS, ATT Y GEN.

                                    Court:  USCA-6                                              Granted:  10/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  2/27/17                                Decided:  5/30/17

                                    Author:  J. Thomas                                        

                                    Result:  REVERSED (NMG   no part)

 

16-74  )1*         CFX     ADVOCATE HEALTH CARE NETWORK V. STAPLETON

16-86  )2*         CFX     SAINT PETER S HEALTHCARE SYSTEM V. KAPLAN

16-258)3*         CFX     DIGNITY HEALTH V. ROLLINS

                                    Court:  1USCA-7; 2USCA-3; 3USCA-9          Granted:  12/2/16

                                    Argument Date:  3/27/17                                Decided:  6/5/17

                                    Author:  J. Kagan                                            Other:  Sotomayor (C)

                                    Result:  REVERSED (NMG   no part)

 

16-142*           CFY     HONEYCUTT V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-6                                              Granted:  12/9/16

                                    Argument Date:  3/29/17                                Decided:  6/5/17

                                    Author:  J. Sotomayor

                                    Result:  REVERSED (NMG   no part)

 

16-149*           CSX    COVENTRY HEALTH CARE OF MISSOURI V. NEVILS

                                    Court:  SC-MO                                               Granted:  11/4/16

                                    Argument Date:  3/1/17                                  Decided:  4/18/17

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg                                        Other:  Thomas (C)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (NMG   no part)

 

16-240             CSY    WEAVER V. MASSACHUSETTS

                                    Court:  SJC-MA                                              Granted:  1/13/17

                                    Argument Date:  4/19/17                                Decided:  6/22/17

                                    Author:  J. Kennedy                                        Other:  Thomas (C); Alito (C/J)

                                                                                                                        Breyer (D)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

16-254*           CSX    WATER SPLASH V. MENON

                                    Court:  CA-TX, 14th Dist.                                Granted:  12/2/16

                                    Argument Date:  3/22/17                                Decided:  5/22/17

                                    Author:  J. Alito                                              

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED (NMG   no part)

 

16-309#           CFY     MASLENJAK V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-6                                              Granted:  1/13/17

                                    Argument Date:  4/26/17                                Decided:  6/22/17

                                    Author:  J. Kagan                                            Other:  Gorsuch (C/P, C/J); Alito (C/J)

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

16-327             CFH    LEE V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-6                                              Granted:  12/14/16

                                    Argument Date:  3/28/17                                Decided:  6/23/17

                                    Author:  Chief Justice                                     Other:  Thomas (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (NMG   no part)

 

16-341*           CFX     TC HEARTLAND V. KRAFT FOOD BRANDS GROUP

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed                                          Granted:  12/14/16

                                    Argument Date:  3/27/17                                Decided:  5/22/17

                                    Author:  J. Thomas                                        

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (NMG   no part)

 

16-348             CFX     MIDLAND FUNDING V. JOHNSON

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                            Granted:  10/11/16

                                    Argument Date:  1/17/17                                Decided:  5/15/17

                                    Author:  J. Breyer                                           Other:  Sotomayor (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED (NMG   no part)

 

16-349*           CFX     HENSON V. SANTANDER CONSUMER USA

                                    Court:  USCA-4                                              Granted:  1/13/17

                                    Argument Date:  4/18/17                                Decided:  6/12/17

                                    Author:  J. Gorsuch

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

16-369*           CFX     COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES V. MENDEZ

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  12/2/16

                                    Argument Date:  3/22/17                                Decided:  5/30/17

                                    Author:  J. Alito

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED (NMG   no part)

 

16-373             CFX     CALIFORNIA PUBLIC EMPLOYEES  RETIREMENT SYS. V. ANZ SECURITIES

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  1/13/17

                                    Argument Date:  4/17/17

 

16-399             CFX     PERRY V. MERIT SYSTEMS PROTECTION BD.

                                    Court:  USCA-DC                                           Granted:  1/13/17

                                    Argument Date:  4/17/17                                Decided:  6/23/17

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg                                        Other:  Gorsuch (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

16-405             CSX    BNSF RAILWAY CO. V. TYRELL

                                    Court:  SC-MT                                                            Granted:  1/13/17

                                    Argument Date:  4/25/17                                Decided:  5/30/17

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg                                        Other:  Sotomayor (C/P, D/P)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

16-466             CSX    BRISTOL-MYERS SQUIBB CO. V. SUPERIOR COURT OF CAL.,

                                     SAN FRANCISCO CTY.

                                    Court:  SC-CA                                                            Granted:  1/19/17

                                    Argument Date:  4/25/17                                Decided:  6/19/17

                                    Author:  J. Alito                                               Other:  Sotomayor (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

16-529*           CFX     KOKESH V. SEC

                                    Court:  USCA-10                                            Granted:  1/13/17

                                    Argument Date:  4/18/17                                Decided:  6/5/17

                                    Author:  J. Sotomayor                                               

                                    Result:  REVERSED

 

16-605*           CFX     TOWN OF CHESTER, NY V. LAROE ESTATES

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  1/13/17

                                    Argument Date:  4/17/17                                Decided:  6/5/17

                                    Author:  J. Alito                                  

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

16-5294           CFH    McWILLIAMS V. DUNN, COMM R, ALABAMA DOC

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                            Granted:  1/13/17

                                    Argument Date:  4/24/17                                Decided:  6/19/17

                                    Author:  J. Breyer                                           Other:  Alito (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

16-6219           CFH    DAVILA V. DAVIS, DIR., TX DOCJ

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                              Granted:  1/13/17

                                    Argument Date:  4/24/17

NOTE:

 

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

 

15-486             CFX     IVY V. MORATH, TX COMM R OF EDU.

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                              Granted:  6/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  11/7/16

                                    Date:  10/14/16   Removed from the argument calendar for 11/7/16

                                    Order:  10/31/16

                                    Result:  DISMISSED AS MOOT; VACATED & REMANDED

 

15-961)            CFX     VISA INC. V. OSBORN

15-962)            CFX     VISA INC. V. STOUMBOS

                                    Court:  USCA-DC                                           Granted:  6/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  12/7/16

                                    Order:  11/17/16

                                    Result:  DISMISSED AS IMPROVIDENTLY GRANTED

 

15-1491           CFX     MUSNUFF V. HAEGER

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  9/29/16

                                    Date:  10/25/16

                                    Result:  DISMISSED   Rule 46

 

16-273             CFX     GLOUCESTER COUNTY SCHOOL BD. V. G. G.

                                    Court:  USCA-4                                              Granted:  10/28/16

                                    Argument Date:  3/28/17

                                    Order:  3/6/17

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

No. of Cases (No. of Arguments) made available76 (67)

No. of Cases (No. of Arguments) Argued:  71 (64)       

No. of Cases (No. of Arguments) Disposed of:  70 (61) 

 

Disposed of With Argument

            By Signed Opinion/Judgment   65 (58)      By Per Curiam Opinion                  Dismissed/Other  

 

        Disposed of Without Argument

            By Signed Opinion/Judgment -                 By Per Curiam Opinion                 Dismissed/Other   5 (3)

 

No. of Opinions58 (Signed   58; Per Curiam Opinion   0)

 

CASE CODE KEY

 

q  First Letter  =  Jurisdictional Grounds  (ex. 13-100  CSX)

 

C  -  Certiorari

A  -  Appeal

Q  -  Certified Question

 

q  Second Letter  =  Court Below  (ex. 13-100  CSX)

 

S  -  State

F  -  U.S. Court of Appeals

T  -  Three-Judge District Court

M  -  U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces

O  -  Other Court

 

q  Third Letter  =  Nature of Case  (ex. 13-100  CSX)

 

X  -  Civil

Y  -  Criminal

H  -  Habeas Corpus or other collateral attack

 

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES 1 First Street, NE Washington, DC 20543