Skip Navigation LinksHome > Case Documents > Granted/Noted Cases List > October Term 2020

20 GN List 4-5-21

 

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

 

GRANTED & NOTED LIST

 

OCTOBER TERM 2020 CASES FOR ARGUMENT

 

As of April 5, 2021

 

65, Orig.                       TEXAS V. NEW MEXICO

                                    Order:  1/27/20   River Master s final determination - Set for oral argument

                                    Argument Date:  4/21/20

                                    Date:  4/3/20   Argument Postponed:  4/13/20   Reschedule for 2020 Term

                                    Rescheduled Argument Date:  10/5/20                Decided:  12/14/20

                                    Author:  J. Kavanaugh                                       Other:  Alito (C/J/P & D/P)

                                    Result:  MOTION DENIED (ACB   no part)

 

142, Orig.*                    FLORIDA V. GEORGIA

                                    Order:  10/5/20   Exceptions to Second Report of Special Master   Set for oral argument

                                    Argument Date:  2/22/21                                    Decided:  4/1/21

                                    Author:  J. Barrett

                                    Result:  EXCEPTIONS OVERRULED, AND CASE DISMISSED

 

18-540*             CFX      RUTLEDGE, ATT Y GEN. OF AR V. PHARMACEUTICAL CARE MANAGEMENT ASSN.

                                    Court:  USCA-8                                                 Granted:  1/10/20

                                    Argument Date:  4/27/20

                                    Date:  4/3/20   Argument Postponed:  4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term

                                    Rescheduled Argument Date:  10/6/20                Decided:  12/10/20

                                    Author:  J. Sotomayor                                       Other:  Thomas (C)

                                    Result:  REVERSED and REMANDED (ACB   no part)

                       

 

18-956              CFX      GOOGLE LLC V. ORACLE AMERICA, INC.

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed.                                            Granted:  11/15/19

                                    Argument Date:  3/24/20

                                    Date:  3/16/20   Argument Postponed:  4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term

                                    Rescheduled Argument Date:  10/7/20                Decided:  4/5/21

                                    Author:  J. Breyer                                              Other:  Thomas (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (ACB   no part)

 

18-1259             CSY     JONES V. MISSISSIPPI

                                    Court:  SC-MS                                                   Granted:  3/9/20

                                    Argument Date:  11/3/20

 

18-1447             CFX      REPUBLIC OF HUNGARY V. SIMON

                                    Court:  USCA-DC                                              Granted:  7/2/20

                                    Argument Date:  12/7/20                                    Decided:  2/3/21

                                    Author:  Per Curiam

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED   

 

19-71*               CFX      TANZIN V. TANVIR

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                                     Granted:  11/22/19

                                    Argument Date:  3/24/20

                                    Date:  3/16/20   Argument Postponed:  4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term

                                    Rescheduled Argument Date:  10/6/20                Decided:  12/10/20

                                    Author:  J. Thomas       

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED (ACB   no part)                  

 

           

19-108)*            CMY     UNITED STATES V. BRIGGS

19-184)*            CMY     UNITED STATES V. COLLINS 

                                    Court:  USCA-AF                                               Granted:  11/15/19

                                    Argument Date:  3/23/20

                                    Date:  3/16/20   Argument Postponed:  4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term

                                    Rescheduled Argument Date:  10/13/20              Decided:  12/10/20

                                    Author:  J. Alito                                                 Other:  Gorsuch (C)

                                    Result:  REVERSED and REMANDED (ACB   no part)

 

19-123              CFX      FULTON V. CITY OF PHILADELPHIA, PA

                                    Court:  USCA-3                                                 Granted:  2/24/20

                                    Argument Date:  11/4/20

 

19-199              CFX      SALINAS V. RAILROAD RETIREMENT BD.

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                                 Granted:  1/10/20

                                    Argument Date:  11/2/20                                    Decided:  2/3/21

                                    Author:  J. Sotomayor                                       Other:  Thomas (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

19-251)             CFX      AMERICANS FOR PROSPERITY V. RODRIQUEZ, ACTING ATT Y GEN. OF CA

19-255)             CFX      THOMAS MORE LAW CENTER V. RODRIQUEZ, ACTING ATT Y GEN. OF CA

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                                 Granted:  1/8/21

                                    Argument Date:  4/26/21

 

19-292              CFX      TORRES V. MADRID

                                    Court:  USCA-10                                                Granted:  12/18/19

                                    Argument Date:  3/30/20

                                    Date:  3/16/20   Argument Postponed:  4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term

                                    Rescheduled Argument Date:  10/14/20              Decided:  3/25/21

                                    Author:  Chief Justice                                        Other:  Gorsuch (D)

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED (ACB   no part)

 

19-309*             CFX      CARNEY, GOV. OF DE V. ADAMS

                                    Court:  USCA-3                                                 Granted:  12/6/19

                                    Argument Date:  3/25/20

                                    Date:  3/16/20   Argument Postponed:  4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term

                                    Rescheduled Argument Date:  10/5/20                Decided:  12/10/20

                                    Author:  J. Breyer                                              Other:  Sotomayor (C)

                                    Result:  VACATED and REMANDED (ACB   no part)

 

19-351*             CFX      FEDERAL REPUBLIC OF GERMANY V. PHILIPP

                                    Court:  USCA-DC                                              Granted:  7/2/20

                                    Argument Date:  12/7/20                                    Decided:  2/3/21

                                    Author:  Chief Justice                                       

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

19-357*             CFX      CITY OF CHICAGO, IL V. FULTON

                                    Court:  USCA-7                                                 Granted:  12/18/19

                                    Argument Date:  4/20/20

                                    Date:  4/3/20   Argument Postponed:  4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term

                                    Rescheduled Argument Date:  10/13/20              Decided:  1/14/21

                                    Author:  J. Alito                                                 Other:  Sotomayor (C)

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED (ACB   no part)

 

19-368)1 #         CSX     FORD MOTOR CO. V. MONTANA EIGHTH JUDICIAL DIST. COURT

19-369)2#          CSX     FORD MOTOR CO. V. BANDEMER

                                    Court:  1SC-MT; 2SC-MN                                    Granted:  1/17/20

                                    Argument Date:  4/27/20

                                    Date:  4/3/20   Argument Postponed:  4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term

                                    Rescheduled Argument Date:  10/7/20                Decided:  3/25/21

                                    Author:  J. Kagan                                              Other:  Alito (C/J):  Gorsuch (C/J)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED (ACB   no part)

 

19-416)             CFX      NESTLE USA, INC. V. DOE I

19-453)             CFX      CARGILL, INC. V. DOE I

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                                 Granted:  7/2/20

                                    Argument Date:  12/1/20

 

19-422)             CFX      COLLINS V. YELLEN, SEC. OF TREASURY

19-563)             CFX      YELLEN, SEC. OF TREASURY V. COLLINS

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                                 Granted:  7/9/20

                                    Argument Date:  12/9/20

 

19-438              CFH      PEREIDA V. WILKINSON

                                    Court:  USCA-8                                                 Granted:  12/18/19

                                    Argument Date:  3/30/20

                                    Date:  3/16/20   Argument Postponed:  4/13/20 - Reschedule for 2020 Term

                                    Rescheduled Argument Date:  10/14/20              Decided:  3/4/21

                                    Author:  J. Gorsuch                                           Other:  Breyer (D)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED (ACB   no part)

 

19-508               CFX      AMG CAPITAL MGMT., LLC V. FTC

                                    Courts:  USCA-9                                                Granted:  7/9/20

                                    Order Date:  11/9/20   No longer consolidated with No. 19-825

                                    Argument Date:  1/13/21

 

19-511#             CFX      FACEBOOK, INC. V. DUGUID

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                                 Granted:  7/9/20

                                    Argument Date:  12/8/20                                    Decided:  4/1/21

                                    Author:  J. Sotomayor                                       Other:  Alito (C/J)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

19-546*             CFX      BROWNBACK V. KING

                                    Court:  USCA-6                                                 Granted:  3/30/20

                                    Argument Date:  11/9/20                                    Decided:  2/25/21

                                    Author:  J. Thomas                                            Other:  Sotomayor (C)

                                    Result:  REVERSED

 

19-547              CFX      UNITED STATES FISH AND WILDLIFE SERV. V. SIERRA CLUB, INC.

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                                 Granted:  3/2/20

                                    Argument Date:  11/2/20                                    Decided:  3/4/21

                                    Author:  J. Barrett                                              Other:  Breyer (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

19-783              CFY      VAN BUREN V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                                Granted:  4/20/20

                                    Argument Date:  11/30/20

 

19-840  )           CFX      CALIFORNIA V. TEXAS

19-1019)           CFX      TEXAS V. CALIFORNIA

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                                 Granted:  3/2/20

                                    Argument Date:  11/10/20

 

19-863              CFX      NIZ-CHAVEZ V. GARLAND, ATT Y GEN.

                                    Court:  USCA-6                                                 Granted:  6/8/20

                                    Argument Date:  11/9/20

 

19-897              CFX      JOHNSON, ACTING DIRECTOR OF U.S. ICE V. CHAVEZ

                                    Court:  USCA-4                                                 Granted:  6/15/20

                                    Argument Date:  1/11/21

 

19-930              CFX      CIC SERVICES, LLC V. IRS

                                    Court:  USCA-6                                                 Granted:  5/4/20

                                    Argument Date:  12/1/20

 

19-968              CFX      UZUEGBUNAM V. PRECZEWSKI

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                                Granted:  7/9/20

                                    Argument Date:  1/12/21                                    Decided:  3/8/21

                                    Author:  J. Thomas                                            Other:  Kavanaugh (C); Chief Justice (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

19-1039             CFX      PENNEAST PIPELINE CO., LLC V. NEW JERSEY

                                    Court:  USCA-3                                                 Granted:  2/3/21

                                    Argument Date:  4/28/21

 

19-1155)           CFX      GARLAND, ATT Y GEN. V. DAI

19-1156)           CFX      GARLAND, ATT Y GEN. V. ALCARAZ-ENRIQUEZ

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                                 Granted:  10/2/20 

                                    Argument Date:  2/23/21

 

19-1189             CFX      BP P.L.C. V. MAYOR AND CITY COUNCIL OF BALTIMORE

                                    Court:  USCA-4                                                 Granted:  10/2/20 (SAA   no part)

                                    Argument Date:  1/19/21

 

19-1212             CFX      MAYORKAS, SEC. OF HOMELAND SECURITY V. INNOVATION LAW LAB

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                                 Granted:  10/19/20

                                    Argument Date:  3/1/21

                                    Order Date:  2/3/21   Further briefing held in abeyance, and case removed from the                                                         February 2021 argument calendar

 

19-1231)*          CFX      FCC V. PROMETHEUS RADIO PROJECT

19-1241)*          CFX      NATIONAL ASSN. OF BROADCASTERS V. PROMETHEUS RADIO PROJECT

                                    Court:  USCA-3                                                 Granted:  10/2/20 

                                    Argument Date:  1/19/21                                    Decided:  4/1/21

                                    Author:  J. Kavanaugh                                       Other:  Thomas (C)

                                    Result:  REVERSED

 

19-1257)           CFX      BRNOVICH, ATT Y GEN. OF AZ V. DEMOCRATIC NATIONAL COMMITTEE

19-1258)           CFX      AZ REPUBLICAN PARTY V. DEMOCRATIC NATIONAL COMMITTEE

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                                 Granted:  10/2/20

                                    Argument Date:  3/2/21

 

19-1328             CFX      DEPT. OF JUSTICE V. HOUSE COMMITTEE ON THE JUDICIARY

                                    Court:  USCA-DC                                              Granted:  7/2/20

                                    Argument Date:  12/2/20

                                    Order Date:  11/20/20   Removed from the December 2020 Argument Calendar

 

19-1414             CFY      UNITED STATES V. COOLEY

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                                 Granted:  11/20/20

                                    Argument Date:  3/23/21

 

19-1434)           CFX      UNITED STATES V. ARTHREX, INC.

19-1452)           CFX      SMITH & NEPHEW, INC. V. ARTHREX, INC.

19-1458)           CFX      ARTHREX, INC. V. SMITH & NEPHEW, INC.

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed.                                            Granted:  10/13/20

                                    Argument Date:  3/1/21

 

19-1442)1          CFX      CARR v. SAUL

20-105 )2          CFX      DAVIS V. SAUL

                                    Court:  1USCA-10; 2USCA-8                               Granted:  11/9/20

                                    Argument Date:  3/3/21

 

19-5410             CFY      BORDEN V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-6                                                 Granted:  3/2/20

                                    Argument Date:  11/3/20

 

19-5807             CFH      EDWARDS V. VANNOY

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                                 Granted:  5/4/20

                                    Argument Date:  12/2/20

 

19-8709             CFY      GREER V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                                Granted:  1/8/21

                                    Argument Date:  4/20/21

 

20-18                CSY     LANGE V. CALIFORNIA

                                    Court:  CA-CA, 1st App. Dist.                             Granted:  10/19/20

                                    Argument Date:  2/24/21

 

20-37)               CFX      BECERRA, SEC. OF H&HS V. GRESHAM

20-38)               CFX      ARKANSAS V. GRESHAM

                                    Court:  USCA-DC                                              Granted:  12/4/20

                                    Argument Date:  3/29/21

                                    Date:  3/11/21   Removed from calendar for March 2021 argument session

                                    Order Date:  4/5/21 - Cases held in abeyance pending further order of Court.

 

20-107              CFX      CEDAR POINT NURSERY V. HASSID

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                                 Granted:  11/13/20

                                    Argument Date:  3/22/21

 

20-138              CFX      BIDEN, PRESIDENT OF U.S. V. SIERRA CLUB

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                                 Granted:  10/19/20

                                    Argument Date:  2/22/21

                                    Order Date:  2/3/21   Further briefing held in abeyance, and case removed from the                                                         February 2021 argument calendar

 

20-157              CFX      CANIGLIA V. STROM

                                    Court:  USCA-1                                                 Granted:  11/20/20

                                    Argument Date:  3/24/21

 

20-222              CFX      GOLDMAN SACHS GROUP V. AR TEACHER RETIREMENT

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                                 Granted:  12/11/20

                                    Argument Date:  3/29/21

 

20-255              CFX      MAHANOY AREA SCHOOL DIST. V. B. L.

                                    Court:  USCA-3                                                 Granted:  1/8/21

                                    Argument Date:  4/28/21

 

20-297              CFX      TRANSUNION LLC V. RAMIREZ

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                                 Granted:  12/16/20

                                    Argument Date:  3/30/21

 

20-315              CFX      SANCHEZ V. MAYORKAS, SEC. OF HOMELAND SECURITY

                                    Court:  USCA-3                                                 Granted:  1/8/21

                                    Argument Date:  4/19/21

 

20-334              CFX      CITY OF SAN ANTONIO, TX V. HOTELS.COM, L.P.

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                                 Granted:  1/8/21

                                    Argument Date:  4/21/21

 

20-366              ATX      TRUMP, PRESIDENT OF U.S. V. NEW YORK

                                    Court:  USDC-S. Dist., NY                                 Juris Postponed:  10/16/20

                                    Argument Date:  11/30/20                                  Decided:  12/18/20

                                    Author:  Per Curiam                                           Other:  Breyer (D)

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

20-382              CFX      GUAM V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-DC                                              Granted:  1/8/21

                                    Argument Date:  4/26/21

 

20-437              CFY      UNITED STATES V. PALOMAR-SANTIAGO

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                                 Granted:  1/8/21

                                    Argument Date:  4/27/21

 

20-440              CFX      MINERVA SURGICAL, INC. V. HOLOGIC, INC.

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed                                             Granted:  1/8/21

                                    Argument Date:  4/21/21

 

20-444              CFY      UNITED STATES V. GARY

                                    Court:  USCA-4                                                 Granted:  1/8/21

                                    Argument Date:  4/20/21

 

20-472              CFX      HOLLYFRONTIER CHEYENNE REFINING, LLC V. RENEWABLE FUELS ASSN.

                                    Court:  USCA-10                                                Granted:  1/8/21

                                    Argument Date:  4/27/21

 

20-512)             CFX      NCAA V. ALSTON

20-520)             CFX      AM. ATHLETIC CONFERENCE V. ALSTON

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                                 Granted:  12/16/20

                                    Argument Date:  3/31/21

 

20-543)             CFX      YELLEN, SEC. OF TREASURY V. CONFEDERATED TRIBES OF THE CHEHALIS                            

           )                         RESERVATION

20-544)             CFX      ALASKA NATIVE VILLAGE CORP. V. CONFEDERATED TRIBES OF THE CHEHALIS

                                     RESERVATION

                                    Court:  USCA-DC                                              Granted:  1/8/21

                                    Argument Date:  4/19/21

 

20-5904             CFY      TERRY V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                                Granted:  1/8/21

                                    Argument Date:  4/20/21

                                    Date:  3/19/21   Removed from April 2021 argument calendar

                                    Rescheduled Argument Date:  5/4/21

 

NOTE:

 

19-825              CFX      FTC V. CREDIT BUREAU CENTER

                                    Courts:  USCA-7                                                Granted:  7/9/20 (see 11/9/20 order)

                                    Order:  11/9/20   No longer consolidated with No. 19-508, and 7/9/20 order granting                                                         certiorari vacated (ACB   no part)

 

19-963              CFX      HENRY SCHEIN, INC. V. ARCHER AND WHITE SALES, INC.

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                                 Granted:  6/15/20

                                    Argument Date:  12/8/20                                    Decided:  1/25/21

                                    Author:  Per Curiam

                                    Result:  DISMISSED AS IMPROVIDENTLY GRANTED

 

Cases (Arguments) Made Available:  66 (52)

Cases (Arguments) Available per Rescheduling from 2019 Term:  12 (10)

TOTAL Available for Argument:  78 (62)

Cases (Arguments) Disposed of Without Argument:  1*

     -   By Signed Opinion/Judgment:         

     -   By Per Curiam Opinion: 

     -   Dismissed: 

     -   Other:  *1 (No. 19-825 grant order vacated   case pending)

Cases (Arguments) Argued:  57 (45)

Cases (Arguments) Disposed of With Argument:  24 (21)

     -   By Signed Opinion/Judgment:  21 (18) 

     -   By Per Curiam Opinion:  2 (2)

     -   Dismissed Improvidently Granted/Other:  1 (1)

No. of Opinions[i] for Argued Cases:  21

 

 

CASE CODE KEY

 

q  First Letter  =  Jurisdictional Grounds  (ex. 20-000  CSX)

 

C  -  Certiorari

A  -  Appeal

Q  -  Certified Question

 

q  Second Letter  =  Court Below  (ex. 20-000  CSX)

 

S  -  State

F  -  U.S. Court of Appeals

T  -  Three-Judge District Court

M  -  U.S. Court of Appeals for the Armed Forces

O  -  Other Court

 

q  Third Letter  =  Nature of Case  (ex. 20-000  CSX)

 

X  -  Civil

Y  -  Criminal

H  -  Habeas Corpus or other collateral attack

 

 



[i] NOTE:   *Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

 

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES 1 First Street, NE Washington, DC 20543