Skip Navigation LinksHome | Orders and Journal | Granted & Noted List - October Term 2012
 
 
 
 
OT2012 Granted/Noted List

 

SUPREME COURT OF THE UNITED STATES

OCTOBER TERM 2012 - GRANTED & NOTED LIST

 

As of May 20, 2013

 

10-930*           CFX     RYAN, DIR., AZ DOC V. GONZALES

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  3/19/12

                                    Argument Date:  10/9/12                                Decided w/No. 11-218:  1/8/13

                                    Author:  J. Thomas

                                    Result:  REVERSED (opinion combined with No. 11-218)

 

11-184*           CFX     KLOECKNER V. SOLIS, SEC. OF LABOR

                                    Court:  USCA-8                                              Granted:  1/13/12

                                    Argument Date:  10/2/12                                Decided:  12/10/12

                                    Author:  J. Kagan

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

11-192*           CFX     UNITED STATES V. BORMES

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed.                                         Granted:  1/13/12

                                    Argument Date:  10/2/12                                Decided:  11/13/12

                                    Author:  J. Scalia

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

11-218*           CFH    TIBBALS, WARDEN V. CARTER

                                    Court:  USCA-6                                              Granted:  3/19/12

                                    Argument Date:  10/9/12                                Decided w/No. 10-930:  1/8/13

                                    Author:  J. Thomas

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (opinion combined with No. 10-930)

 

11-338)#          CFX     DECKER V. NORTHWEST ENVTL. DEFENSE CENTER

11-347)#          CFX     GEORGIA-PACIFIC WEST V. NORTHWEST ENVTL. DEFENSE CENTER

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  6/25/12 (SB   no part)

                                    Argument Date:  12/3/12                                Decided:  3/20/13

                                    Author:  J. Kennedy                                        Other:  Chief Justice (C); Scalia (C/P, D/P)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (SB   no part)

 

11-345             CFX     FISHER V. UNIVERSITY OF TEXAS AT AUSTIN

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                              Granted:  2/21/12 (EK   no part)

                                    Argument Date:  10/10/12

 

11-460#           CFX     LOS ANGELES CTY. FLOOD CONTROL V. NATURAL RESOURCES

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  6/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  12/4/12                                Decided:  1/8/13

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg                                        Other:  Alito (C/J)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED     

 

11-465#           CFH    JOHNSON, ACTING WARDEN V. WILLIAMS

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  1/13/12

                                    Argument Date:  10/3/12                                Decided: 2/20/13

                                    Author: J. Alito                                                            Other: Scalia (C/J)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

11-556             CFX     VANCE V. BALL STATE UNIVERSITY

                                    Court:  USCA-7                                              Granted:  6/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  11/26/12

 

11-564             CSY    FLORIDA V. JARDINES

                                    Court:  SC-FL                                                 Granted:  1/6/12

                                    Argument Date:  10/31/12                              Decided:  3/26/13

                                    Author:  J. Scalia                                            Other:  Kagan (C); Alito (D)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

11-597*           CFX     ARKANSAS GAME & FISH COMM. V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed.                                         Granted:  4/2/12 (EK   no part)

                                    Argument Date:  10/3/12                                Decided:  12/4/12

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED (EK   no part)

 

11-626             CFX     LOZMAN V. CITY OF RIVIERA BEACH, FLORIDA

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                            Granted:  2/21/12

                                    Argument Date:  10/1/12                                Decided:  1/15/13

                                    Author:  J. Breyer                                           Other:  Sotomayor (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED

 

11-697             CFX     KIRTSAENG V. JOHN WILEY & SONS, INC.

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  4/16/12

                                    Argument Date:  10/29/12                              Decided:  3/19/13

                                    Author:  J. Breyer                                           Other:  Kagan (C); Ginsburg (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

11-702             CFX     MONCRIEFFE V. HOLDER, ATT Y GEN.

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                              Granted:  4/2/12

                                    Argument Date:  10/10/12                              Decided:  4/23/13

                                    Author:  J. Sotomayor                                                Other:  Thomas (D); Alito (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

11-770             CFY     BAILEY V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  6/4/12

                                    Argument Date:  11/1/12                                Decided:  2/19/13

                                    Author:  J. Kennedy                                        Other: Scalia (C); Breyer (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

11-796*           CFX     BOWMAN V. MONSANTO CO.

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed.                                         Granted:  10/5/12

                                    Argument Date:  2/19/13                                Decided:  5/13/13

                                    Author:  J. Kagan

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

11-798             CFX     AMERICAN TRUCKING ASSNS. V. CITY OF LOS ANGELES, CA

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  1/11/13

                                    Argument Date: 4/16/13

 

11-817*           CSY    FLORIDA V. HARRIS

                                    Court:  SC-FL                                                 Granted:  3/26/12

                                    Argument Date:  10/31/12                              Decided:  2/19/13

                                    Author:  J. Kagan

                                    Result: REVERSED

 

11-820             CFY     CHAIDEZ V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-7                                              Granted:  4/30/12

                                    Argument Date:  11/1/12                                Decided:  2/20/13

                                    Author: J. Kagan                                             Other: Thomas (C/J); Sotomayor (D)

                                    Result: AFFIRMED

 

11-864             CFX     COMCAST CORP. V. BEHREND

                                    Court:  USCA-3                                              Granted:  6/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  11/5/12                                Decided:  3/27/13

                                    Author:  J. Scalia                                            Other: Ginsburg/Breyer (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED

 

11-889             CFX     TARRANT REGIONAL WATER DISTRICT V. HERRMANN

                                    Court:  USCA-10                                            Granted:  1/4/13

                                    Argument Date:  4/23/13

 

11-982*           CFX     ALREADY, LLC V. NIKE, INC.

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  6/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  11/7/12                                Decided:  1/9/13

                                    Author:  Chief Justice                                     Other:  Kennedy (C)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

11-1025           CFX     CLAPPER V. AMNESTY INT L USA

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  5/21/12

                                    Argument Date:  10/29/12                              Decided:  2/26/13

                                    Author:  J. Alito                                               Other:  Breyer (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

11-1059           CFX     GENESIS HEALTHCARE CORP. V. SYMCZYK

                                    Court:  USCA-3                                              Granted:  6/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  12/3/12                                Decided:  4/16/13

                                    Author:  J. Thomas                                         Other:  Kagan (D)

                                    Result:  REVERSED

 

11-1085           CFX     AMGEN, INC. V. CONNECTICUT RETIREMENT PLANS

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  6/11/12 (SB   no part)

                                    Argument Date:  11/5/12                                Decided:  2/27/13

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg                                        Other:  Alito (C); Scalia (D); Thomas (D)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

11-1118*         CSX    GUNN V. MINTON

                                    Court:  SC-TX                                                 Granted:  10/5/12

                                    Argument Date:  1/16/13                                Decided: 2/20/13

                                    Author:  Chief Justice

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED                             

 

11-1160*         CFX     FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION V. PHOEBE PUTNEY HEALTH SYS.

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                            Granted:  6/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  11/26/12                              Decided:  2/19/13

                                    Author: J. Sotomayor

                                    Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

11-1175           CFX     MARX V. GENERAL REVENUE CORP. 

                                    Court:  USCA-10                                            Granted:  5/29/12

                                    Argument Date:  11/7/12                                Decided:  2/26/13

                                    Author:  J. Thomas                                         Other:  Sotomayor (D)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

11-1221           CSX    HILLMAN V. MARETTA

                                    Court:  SC-VA                                                 Granted:  1/11/13

                                    Argument Date:  4/22/13

 

11-1231*         CFX     SEBELIUS, SEC. OF H&HS V. AUBURN REGIONAL MEDICAL CENTER

                                    Court:  USCA-DC                                           Granted:  6/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  12/4/12                                Decided:  1/22/13

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg                                        Other:  Sotomayor (C)

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

 

11-1274*         CFX     GABELLI V. SECURITIES AND EXCHANGE COMMISSION

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  9/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  1/8/13                                  Decided:  2/27/13

                                    Author:  Chief Justice

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

11-1285           CFX     US AIRWAYS, INC. V. McCUTCHEN

                                    Court:  USCA-3                                              Granted:  6/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  11/27/12                              Decided:  4/16/13

                                    Author:  J. Kagan                                            Other:  Scalia (D)

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

11-1327           CSY    EVANS V. MICHIGAN

                                    Court:  SC-MI                                                 Granted:  6/11/12

                                    Argument Date:  11/6/12                                Decided: 2/20/13

                                    Author: J. Sotomayor                                     Other: Alito (D)

                                    Result: REVERSED

 

11-1347*         CFX     CHAFIN V. CHAFIN

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                            Granted:  8/13/12

                                    Argument Date:  12/5/12                                Decided: 2/19/13

                                    Author: Chief Justice                                      Other: Ginsburg (C)

                                    Result: VACATED AND REMANDED

 

11-1351*         CFX     LEVIN V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  9/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  1/15/13                                Decided:  3/4/13

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg               

                                    Result:  REVERSED AND REMANDED                 

 

11-1425           CSY    MISSOURI V. MCNEELY

                                    Court:  SC-MO                                               Granted:  9/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  1/9/13                                  Decided:  4/17/13

                                    Author:  J. Sotomayor                                                Other:  Kennedy (C/P)

                                                                                                                        Chief Justice (C/P, D/P)

                                                                                                                        Thomas (D)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

11-1447           CSX    KOONTZ V. ST. JOHNS RIVER WATER MGMT.

                                    Court:  SC-FL                                                 Granted:  10/5/12

                                    Argument Date:  1/15/13

 

11-1450*         CFX     STANDARD FIRE INSURANCE CO. V. KNOWLES

                                    Court:  USCA-8                                              Granted:  8/31/12

                                    Argument Date:  1/7/13                                  Decided:  3/19/13

                                    Author:  J. Breyer

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

11-1518*         CFX     BULLOCK V. BANKCHAMPAIGN, N. A.

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                            Granted:  10/29/12

                                    Argument Date:  3/18/13                                Decided:  5/13/13

                                    Author:  J. Breyer

                                    Result:  VACATED AND REMANDED

 

11-1545)          CFX     CITY OF ARLINGTON, TX V. FCC

11-1547)          CFX     CABLE, TELECOMMUNICATIONS & TECH V. FCC

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                              Granted:  10/5/12

                                    Argument Date:  1/16/13                                Decided:  5/20/13

                                    Author:  J. Scalia                                            Other:  Breyer (C/P, C/J);

                                                                                                                        Chief Justice (D)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

11-8976*         CFY     SMITH V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-DC                                           Granted:  6/18/12

                                    Argument Date:  11/6/12                                Decided:  1/9/13

                                    Author:  J. Scalia

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

11-9307           CFY     HENDERSON V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                              Granted:  6/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  11/28/12                              Decided: 2/20/13

                                    Author: J. Breyer                                            Other: Scalia (D)

                                    Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

11-9335           CFY     ALLEYNE V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-4                                              Granted:  10/5/12

                                    Argument Date:  1/14/13

 

11-9540           CFY     DESCAMPS V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  8/31/12

                                    Argument Date:  1/7/13

 

11-10189         CFH    TREVINO V. THALER, DIR., TX DCJ

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                              Granted:  10/29/12

                                    Argument Date:  2/25/13

 

11-10362*       CFX     MILLBROOK V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-3                                              Granted:  9/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  2/19/13                                Decided:  3/27/13

                                    Author: J. Thomas                                         

                                    Result: REVERSED AND REMANDED

 

12-10               CFX     AGENCY FOR INT L DEVELOPMENT V. ALLIANCE FOR OPEN SOCIETY INT L

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  1/11/13  (EK   no part)

                                    Argument Date: 4/22/13

 

   

12-17*             CFX     MCBURNEY V. YOUNG

                                    Court:  USCA-4                                              Granted:  10/5/12

                                    Argument Date:  2/20/13                                Decided:  4/29/13

                                    Author:  J. Alito                                               Other:  Thomas (C)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

12-25               CFX     MARACICH V. SPEARS

                                    Court:  USCA-4                                              Granted:  9/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  1/9/13

 

12-43*             CFX     PPL CORP. V. CIR

                                    Court:  USCA-3                                              Granted:  10/29/12

                                    Argument Date:  2/20/13                                Decided:  5/20/13

                                    Author:  J. Thomas                                         Other:  Sotomayor (C)

                                    Result:  REVERSED

 

12-52*             CSX    DAN S CITY USED CARS, INC. V. PELKEY

                                    Court:  SC-NH                                                            Granted:  12/7/12

                                    Argument Date:  3/20/13                                Decided:  5/13/13

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

12-62               CFY     PEUGH V. UNITED STATES

                                    Court:  USCA-7                                              Granted:  11/9/12

                                    Argument Date:  2/26/13

 

12-71               CFX     ARIZONA V. INTER TRIBAL COUNCIL

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  10/15/12

                                    Argument Date:  3/18/13

 

12-96               CFX     SHELBY COUNTY, AL V. HOLDER, ATTY GEN.

                                    Court:  USCA-DC                                           Granted:  11/9/12

                                    Argument Date:  2/27/13

 

12-98               CFX     WOS, SEC., NC DEPT. OF H&HS V. E.M.A.

                                    Court:  USCA-4                                              Granted:  9/25/12

                                    Argument Date:  1/8/13                                  Decided:  3/20/13

                                    Author:  J. Kennedy                                        Other:  Breyer (C); Chief Justice (D)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

12-123             CFX     HORNE V. DEPT. OF AGRICULTURE

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  11/20/12

                                    Argument Date:  3/20/13

 

12-126             CFH    MCQUIGGIN, WARDEN V. PERKINS

                                    Court:  USCA-6                                              Granted:  10/29/12

                                    Argument Date:  2/25/13

 

12-133             CFX     AMERICAN EXPRESS CO. V. ITALIAN COLORS RESTAURANT

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  11/9/12 (SS   no part)

                                    Argument Date:  2/27/13

 

12-135             CFX     OXFORD HEALTH PLANS LLC V. SUTTER

                                    Court:  USCA-3                                              Granted:  12/7/12

                                    Argument Date:  3/25/13

 

12-142             CFX     MUTUAL PHARMACEUTICAL CO. V. BARTLETT

                                    Court:  USCA-1                                              Granted:  11/30/12

                                    Argument Date:  3/18/13

 

12-144             CFX     HOLLINGSWORTH V. PERRY

                                    Court:  USCA-9                                              Granted:  12/7/12

                                    Argument Date:  3/26/13

 

                       

12-167             CFY     UNITED STATES V. DAVILA

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                            Granted:  1/4/13

                                    Argument Date:  4/15/13

 

12-207             CSX    MARYLAND V. KING

                                    Court:  CA-MD                                                Granted:  11/9/12

                                    Argument Date:  2/26/13

 

12-236**#        CFX     SEBELIUS, SEC. H&HS V. CLOER

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed.                                         Granted:  11/20/12

                                    Argument Date:  3/19/13                                Decided:  5/20/13

                                    Author:  J. Sotomayor                                               

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

12-246             CSY    SALINAS V. TEXAS

                                    Court:  Crim App.   TX                                   Granted:  1/11/13

                                    Argument Date: 4/17/13

 

12-307             CFX     UNITED STATES V. WINDSOR

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  12/7/12

                                    Argument Date:  3/27/13

 

12-357             CFY     SEKHAR V. UNITED STATES
                                   
Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  1/11/13

                                    Argument Date: 4/23/13

 

12-398             CFX     ASSN. FOR MOLECULAR PATHOLOGY V. MYRIAD GENETICS

                                    Court:  USCA-Fed.                                         Granted:  11/30/12

                                    Argument Date:  4/15/13

 

12-399             CSX    ADOPTIVE COUPLE V. BABY GIRL

                                    Court:  SC-SC                                                            Granted:  1/4/13

                                    Argument Date:  4/16/13

 

12-416             CFX     FEDERAL TRADE COMMISSION V. ACTAVIS, INC.

                                    Court:  USCA-11                                            Granted:  12/7/12

                                    Argument Date:  3/25/13

 

12-418             CFY     UNITED STATES V. KEBODEAUX

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                              Granted:  1/11/13

                                    Argument Date: 4/17/13

 

12-484             CFX     UNIV. OF TX SOUTHWESTERN MED. CENTER V. NASSAR

                                    Court:  USCA-5                                              Granted:  1/18/13

                                    Argument Date: 4/24/13

 

12-547*           CFH    METRISH, WARDEN V. LANCASTER

                                    Court:  USCA-6                                              Granted:  1/18/13

                                    Argument Date: 4/24/13                                 Decided:  5/20/13

                                    Author:  J. Ginsburg

                                    Result:  REVERSED

 

NOTE:

 

*Unanimous Court/ **Unanimous Court in Part/ #Unanimous in Judgment

 

10-1491#         CFX     KIOBEL V. ROYAL DUTCH PETROLEUM CO.

                                    Court:  USCA-2                                              Granted:  10/17/11

                                    Argument Date:  2/28/12

                                    Order Date:  3/5/12   restored to calendar for reargument

                                    Reargument Date:  10/1/12                            Decided:  4/17/13                   

                                    Author:  Chief Justice                                     Other:  Kennedy (C); Alito (C)

                                                                                                                        Breyer (C/J)

                                    Result:  AFFIRMED

 

11-9953           CSY    BOYER V. LOUISIANA

                                    Court:  CA-LA, 3rd Circuit                               Granted:  10/5/12

                                    Argument Date:  1/14/13                                Decided:  4/29/13

                                    Author:  Per Curiam                                        Other:  Alito (C); Sotomayor (D)

                                    Result:  DISMISSED AS IMPROVIDENTLY GRANTED

 

No. of Cases made available for Argument (Hours)77 (75)

No. of Cases Argued (Hours)77 (75.8)

No. of Cases Disposed of (Hours)47 (45)

 

Disposed of With Argument

               By Signed Opinion/Judgment   46 (44)        By Per Curiam Opinion   1 (1)                Dismissed                           

           

        Disposed of Without Argument

               By Signed Opinion/Judgment -                    By Per Curiam Opinion                          Dismissed    

 

No. of Opinions44 (Signed   43; Per Curiam   1)